Jamie (Mandy Moore) is a girl with excellent academic performance and ordinary appearance. As the daughter of a pastor, she has a firm belief and is not affected by others. Landon (Shane West) is a typical bad student who doesn't like to study, is lazy, and looks down on Jamie, who is alternative and lofty. Because of an excessive prank, Landon was punished to be a tutor in the affiliated school, and he had to play a humble role in a stage play, and the heroine in the play was Jamie, whom he didn't like at all. Jamie's dedication to rehearsal gradually infected Landon, who had just arrived at the troupe. Landon began to invest in the role and changed his opinion of Jamie. However, the confident Jamie actually asked Landon to make a promise that he must not fall in love with himself. During the rehearsal days, the relationship between boys and girls grew quietly. However, Jamie couldn't accept this fact. How could this bad student who didn't want to make progress in front of him become his lover...